1st Reading: Wisdom 9: 13-18
2nd Reading: Philemon: 9b-10, 12-17
Gospel: Luke 14: 25-33
Homily: Myrtle Hendricks-Corrales
The German phrase Sitz im Leben is used in scripture scholarship. It means the social setting or social context or circumstances in which a text or teaching was created. Knowing the history of Israel, the culture, and the social mores of the time enables us to have a deeper understanding of scripture. Let’s look at the story of Abraham and Isaac. First Abraham and Sara are delighted that God has given them a long-wanted child in their old age; then incongruously to test Abraham’s faith, God asked Abraham to sacrifice Isaac. Just as Abraham is about to sacrifice his son, a messenger from God interrupts him and a ram appears. Abraham releases Isaac and sacrifices the ram. This story has traditionally been presented as Abraham’s overwhelming trust in God. However, the Sitz im Leben at the time was that there was human child sacrifice—so perhaps we should look at this story as God presenting the ram to Abraham to instruct him that God does not want human sacrifice.
Another example is the Good Samaritan parable. At that time Israel was divided into two kingdoms: Judah in the South and Samaria in the North. The Samaritans intermarried with their captors, the Assyrians, and over time no longer thought it was necessary to worship in Jerusalem. The Jews in the South hated the Samaritans, considering them half-breeds and no longer Jews. The Samaritans returned the hatred. When Jesus tells the parable of the Good Samaritan, his disciples are not surprised that the priest and the Levite do not stop to help the victim because if they had touched a dead body or blood, they would not meet the purity laws required to worship in the synagogue. Knowing the animosity felt toward Samaritans, we can understand the disciples’ surprise that a worthless, half-breed, adulterated Jew would be kind and aid the victim.
Today, in Paul’s letter to Philemon, we learn that enslaved Onesimus is in prison with Paul, probably because he attempted to flee to freedom. Because enslaved people were an accepted part of the culture, that is the Sitz im Leben, Paul does not request Philemon to free Onesimus—he sends Onesimus back to his master, back to his enslavement. Yet, Paul is radical in his request that Philemon not treat Onesimus as a valuable piece of property but as a person of equal status, to receive him as a beloved brother.
The gospel may appear harsh in declaring that to come to Jesus, one must hate their father, mother, and other family members. Love/hate is a word pair used in the language of international treaties in the biblical world. In covenant contexts, love/hate denotes not deep-seated feelings but rather one’s loyalty or disloyalty to an overlord. The person who “loves” the overlord is faithful, while the one who “hates” the overlord rebels against him. Nevertheless, while recognizing the use of love/hate in this context, Jesus is very clear in warning his disciples that situations will arise that will test their loyalty with him or with members of their family. Jesus demands that he and the work of justice be first in the affections and commitments of his disciples. He requires careful reflection of the costs of discipleship and the willingness to pay.
If new texts were added to the scriptural canon today, what would be the Sitz in Leben? How different would the message be from the existing Hebrew and Christian scriptures? Our contemporary prophets still call for justice for the poor, the end of greed, the termination of corruption in governments, the end of violence, no war, equality, and dignity for all. Much of what would be stated today would repeat most of the biblical message, except for one of our crises in the world today, the Sitz in Leben of our destruction of creation. This new entry into the canon would be a desperate cry to save the Earth, to bring us to ecological responsibility. It would be a call for healing and proper care of creation, the common home for plants, animals, and other living creatures who have much to teach us about caring for the amazing gift of God’s creation.
The PAX Community knows that the world needs to rethink the assumptions about progress and development and to transform the way we live accordingly. We stand with the poor, the marginalized peoples who suffer the most from environmental racism and climate change. We also stand with indigenous peoples who are being evicted from their land and homes.
We know the ugly history of genocide and the dispossession of our own indigenous people in our country and throughout the world. Sadly, indigenous people in the name of progress are still being evicted from their homes and lands. I recently viewed a documentary on an indigenous tribe in Brazil, the Kokama people (Jungle Mystery: Lost Tribes of the Amazon – Netflix). The Brazilian government notified the Kokama that for economic growth, their land will be deforested, and they would have to find new homes. Devastated by this development, the tribe protested to the government declaring that they had been on their land for centuries. The government responded that if they could prove that the tribe has lived on this land for 500 years, the government would not destroy their homes.
Now for decades, members of the tribe have found ancient pottery in the rain forest surrounding their village. They collected and stored the pottery in a special shed. Not trusting the government or archeologists, they had never shared their findings for fear of the pottery being taken from them. The Kokama learned that a European archeologist was studying the rainforest and the indigenous people. They invited her to their village to view the pottery, with the hope that she could date the pottery. Not having the needed expertise, she convinced the chief and the tribe to bring in an expert on pre-Columbian pottery. It was such a touching scene to observe the tribe’s anxiety and nervousness as they surrounded the scientist as he examined the pottery. When the scientist declared that the pottery was at least 1500 years old, the chief wept, the people wept. Their land, their homes were saved. The Kokama had a good outcome, but it does not happen for all people in the rainforest where 20% percent of the Brazilian rainforest has been destroyed.
In this Season of Creation, let’s recommit to work and reflect on what the cost of true discipleship is in the complex ecological, social, economic, and cultural crises facing the Earth community today. There is a great need for the Earth to have time to rest, restore, and recover from the lack of stewardship and the destructive damage from climate change. We must be mindful of the fragility of creation, commit to leaving a small footprint on the environment, and be advocates encouraging our government to support global collaboration and cooperation to save the Earth. Just as Jesus demands to be first in the affection and commitments of his disciples, the crisis of the Earth demands our full commitment and true discipleship in this time of urgent global crisis. We are members of a vast and profoundly interdependent web of life. The precious gift of God. We must work now to save Earth.
The PAX Community is fortunate to have the Caring for Creation Mission Group that continually inspires us and provides opportunities to enjoy and protect our Earth. During this Season of Creation, the Caring for Creation Mission Group will provide us with films, reflections, education, liturgies, and tools so we can all work to save our Earth.
I end with words of hope adapted from the song “If I Can Dream” written in 1968 by Walter Brown. The song is a wish for a better world, which can be attained by the strength and commitment of every person who does not abandon the desire and hope for a better world, by people who will not give up. It goes like this:
There must be lights burning brighter somewhere. Got to be birds flying higher in a sky more blue.
If I can dream of a better land where all my sisters and brothers walk hand in hand, tell me why can’t my dream come true?
There must be peace and understanding sometime. Strong winds of promise that will blow away all the doubt and fear.
If I can dream of a warmer sun where hope keeps shining on everyone, tell me why won’t that sun appear?
We’re lost in a cloud with too much rain, we’re trapped in a world that’s troubled with pain.
But as long as humanity has the strength to dream, we can redeem our souls and fly.
This song was made famous by Elvis Presley.